Easy White Christmas Margarita Pitcher Recipe

A White Christmas Margarita Pitcher Recipe that will not disappoint. This creamy coconut margarita with lime juice, tequila, coconut water and cranberries tastes like summer and looks like Christmas in a cup. It is sure to be a hit at your holiday party and guaranteed to give you the merriest of holidays!

If you like Margarita Pitcher Recipes that you need to make my Blackberry Margaritas or my Blender Frozen Strawberry Margaritas.

white christmas margarita recipe in a glass with cranberries and rosemary

White Christmas Margarita Recipe

I am no mixologist, but let me tell you. This White Christmas Margarita Recipe will have you “rockin around the Christmas tree” for sure!

Not only does it look like Christmas in a cup, but it is incredible smooth. (buyer be ware!) 

As I was working on recipes for this Holiday Entertaining Series I really wanted to focus on recipes that could be made in bulk, and Christmas drinks were no different. This White Christmas Margarita Recipe is made in a Pitcher which allows you to be free and mingle instead of mixing drinks. So, let’s get started shall we!?

overhead photo of white christmas margarita pitcher recipe

This easy Christmas Punch for a Crowd is going to be your new go to for the holidays, I know it will be for me! I plan on making a double batch of this stuff for our annual Ugly Sweater Christmas Party! Woohoo!

MUST-HAVE BAR GLASSWARE 


 

Ingredients you’ll need to make this White Christmas Margarita:

  • Coconut Milk: You’ll want to get the full-fat coconut milk in a can. It is extra creamy and the real deal!
  • Coconut Water: This is a “lighter” way to add more coconut flavor and not as many calories
  • Tequila: Um, this is a must in Margaritas. I’d recommend the silver tequila because it is lighter in color and won’t turn your margarita a golden color.
  • Grand Marnier: This orange flavored liquor is what gives this margarita a flavorful edge above the rest.
  • Lime Juice: The fresh lime juice cuts through the creaminess of the coconut milk and water and gives you that true margarita flavor!
  • Agave: I use agave in my margarita recipes instead of making a simple syrup. I find it’s lighter and not as sweet.
  • Cranberries & Rosemary Sprigs: This is more for the festive colors, not as much for the taste!

overhead photo of white christmas margarita recipe

Do You Use Gold or Silver Tequila for Margaritas?

I like to use silver or blanco tequila. It has a smooth taste and is a younger tequila, so it’s only been aged in the oak barrel for 2 years at most. Gold tequila is aged for much longer and has a stronger taste. Not always ideal for margaritas.

What is the Best Tequila for Margaritas?

  1. Patron Silver –  It’s a great place to start when drinking tequila. It is made with agave without being too overwhelming. It’s smooth and definitely a good cocktail mixer.
  2. Hornitos – This is a newer tequila to me. A friend of mine turned me on to it and I really like it. I tend to go with the resposado or the anejo for less agave forward taste.
  3. Don Julio – Hands down, this one is my husbands favorite! It is smooth and won’t leave you with a headache because it’s made well.

white christmas margarita recipe in a pitcher

How to Make a White Christmas Margarita Pitcher Recipe?

  1. To a large pitcher add full fat coconut milk, coconut water, grand marnier, silver tequila, lime juice and agave syrup. Using a whisk stir everything together until coconut milk no longer separates.
  2. Serve over ice.
  3. Garnish with fresh cranberries, lime slices and rosemary sprig.

SHOP MY FAVORITE BEVERAGE PITCHERS

 

How Long do Homemade Margaritas Last in the Fridge?

Homemade margaritas should last between 2 to 3 weeks in the refrigerator if kept in an air tight container. For this White Christmas Margarita Recipe you will just need to use a whisk to mix the coconut milk back up again as it tends to separate when it sits.

easy white christmas margarita pitcher recipe

I have legit made this recipe probably 5 times in the past 2 months. Granted I was testing it out the first two times, but still. It is amazing! It’s creamy, smooth, a slight tropical flavor and has a nice zing from the lime juice. Plus it looks like the holidays from the cranberries and rosemary. 

This is one recipe I am seriously so so proud of and cannot wait for you guys to try it! I hope it makes an appearance at your holiday parties! And remember it’s perfect for a crowd because it’s made in a pitcher!

Cheers friends!

More Holiday Cocktail Recipes You’ll Love:

close up of white christmas margarita recipe in a glass and garnished

Print
easy white christmas margarita pitcher recipe

Easy White Christmas Margarita Pitcher Recipe

  • Author: Krista
  • prep_time Prep Time: 5 minutes
  • total_time Total Time: 5 minutes
  • yield Yield: 6-7 1x
  • category Category: Cocktails
  • method Method: Mix
  • cuisine Cuisine: American

Description

A White Christmas Margarita Pitcher Recipe that will not disappoint. This creamy coconut margarita with lime juice, tequila, coconut water and cranberries tastes like summer and looks like Christmas in a cup. 

Scale

Ingredients

  • 18 oz. coconut milk (in can)
  • 6 oz. coconut water
  • 6 oz. grand marnier
  • 9 oz. silver tequila
  • 1/2 cup lime juice
  • 3 tablespoons agave syrup
  • garnish: fresh or frozen cranberries, lime slices and rosemary sprigs

Instructions

  1. To a large pitcher add full fat coconut milk, coconut water, grand marnier, silver tequila, lime juice and agave syrup. Using a whisk stir everything together until coconut milk no longer separates.
  2. Serve over ice.
  3. Garnish with fresh cranberries, lime slices and rosemary sprig.

Nutrition

  • Serving Size: 6 oz.
  • Calories: 305
  • Sugar: 15 g
  • Sodium: 5 g
  • Fat: 12 g
  • Saturated Fat: 11 g
  • Carbohydrates: 17 g
  • Fiber: 0 g
  • Protein: 0 g
  • Cholesterol: 0 mg

Keywords: white christmas margarita, margarita pitcher recipe, margarita recipe, holiday cocktail recipes, pitcher of margarita recipe, margarita recipe for pitcher, christmas margarita, white christmas margarita punch, christmas cocktails, christmas drinks, christmas drinks, how to make a margarita, best margarita recipe

pinterest image for an easy white christmas margarita pitcher recipe

pinterest image for easy white christmas margarita pitcher recipe

pinterest image for an easy white christmas margarita pitcher recipe

DON’T MISS A RECIPE ->

FACEBOOK | TWITTER | PINTEREST | BLOGLOVIN | INSTAGRAM

Hey There

Krista
Hi! I'm the recipe developer and food photographer behind all these easy healthy recipes! I love food, Jesus, morning lattes, and am obsessed with fantasy football!

Related Posts

40 Responses
  1. Ame

    Love this recipe! I used Cointreau b/c the store was out of Grand Marnier and only a 13oz can of coconut milk. I thought the coconut flavor was perfect. I don’t want to be smacked in the face with it and this is still a margarita at heart, so I didn’t want to lose the lime flavor. For those wanting more coconut, try coconut extract or coconut vodka/rum. I used an immersion blender to make everything smooth. The leftovers the next day were even better, as it had thickened slightly and the flavors melded nicely. In the future, I will make this a day ahead on purpose. Thanks for the tasty and beautiful recipe!

  2. Tara

    I loved this tasty recipe and will be making it again. The only problem I had was getting the coconut milk to not be chunky.

  3. Katanna

    This was the single most disgusting drink I’ve ever made, don’t waste your tequila. I love a strong drinks but this just tasted terrible.

  4. Mark

    This didn’t taste good at all. Very strong alcohol taste and couldn’t taste much else. Didn’t taste anything like a margarita. Really wanted to like it, served it at Christmas 🙁

    1. Krista

      Oh I’ms so sorry to hear that. It shouldn’t taste like a true margarita, it will be more tropical tasting for sure with a hint of lime and tequila. I’m sorry you didn’t like it.

  5. Lindsey

    Loved this! I could see how it’s not for everyone but I loved it! One note though, for someone that doesn’t have much experience w coconut milk, when I first opened the can, I almost threw it out thinking it had gone “bad” because it had completely separated. After slightly warming and whisking, it finally took the consistency of “milk” or “cream”. Glad I didn’t throw it out!! Lol

  6. Jenny Craig

    Looks beautiful! My BFF & I try new Christmas cocktails every year & couldn’t wait to try this!! Unfortunately, it did not make us merry & bright. We felt like it was too much lime & was missing a more robust creaminess. We added more agave & then some Malibu & we got through our first glass. Back to the drawing board for us.

    1. Krista

      Oh I’m sorry to hear that Jenny. Yes, I tend to like my margaritas more limey than creamy. DIdn’t want to feel like I was drinking milk. Ya know. I’d recommend using coconut tequila to make it taste more creamy or increasing the coconut milk and blending to break up the coconut milk.

  7. Tracey

    Not much coconut flavor. Same as other reviews drinking because I dont want to waste the tequilla!. Next time I’ll try with coconut rum.

  8. Jarmila Maddox

    Question: can you post a picture or send me a picture of the coconut milk you use? Want to be I use the same thing. Or which coconut cream would you use?
    Thank you
    Jarmila

    1. Krista

      I actually don’t know how to do that on here. I’ve used Thai Kitchen Brand and Goya .. full fat coconut milk. Both are in a can in the international food aisle.

      1. Wanda

        I made this recipe to finish up Christmas 2020 and it came out great. My husband and I love it. I wish I could upload a picture. But, like many other reviews I definitely would want a little bit of more coconut flavor ( I’m Puertorican and I love the coconut flavor as one of our favorite drinks is piña coladas). Definitely will be making this again. Thanks for a great recipe. I use pomegranate for decoration instead of cranberries. It came out beautiful!

    1. Krista

      I’ve made them up to 2-3 days ahead of time. Just remember the coconut milk will harden when in the refrigerator. So I would remove it from the fridge 30 minutes prior to serving and then use a whisk to stir and break up the solidified coconut milk.

    2. Darci

      Hey! I’m bummed that the reviews don’t look very positive, but I’ll still give it a try. Coconut cream and margaritas are my jam! How can it go wrong? I’ll let you know! They’re beautiful 😉

  9. Kathleen

    I notice that on your “Easy White Christmas Margarita Pitcher” recipe. That it looked like your beautiful pic of the glasses full of this cocktail had either salt or sugar around the rim of the glasses. If this is true, what did it have around the rim of the glasses? If the glasses had nothing around the rim. Then I’m sorry to waste your time. But, I can’t wait to make these has I’m planning to make these for 6 different couples. Then with the virus, just dropping them off at the front door and ringing their door bell. To keep us all safe and maybe just a little bit merrier…

    1. Krista

      Good eye Kathleen! Yes I did a sugar lime rim around them to make them pop for the pictures. They are good without the rim but it does a little some some if you choose to add it. Such a fun idea to do for your friends by the way! LOVE it!

    2. PK

      Comments seem to believe this was posted as a coconut marg and it was posted as a White x-mas marg. Sub regular tequila for 1800 coconut tequila and add some coconut cream. Wala, White Coconut X-mas Margarita!!

  10. Isabella

    All my guests loved it! Definitely recommend. So many holiday cocktails are all heavy cream, egg whites, etc. so I love the coconut milk concept.

  11. Gina

    Was this recipe healthy, yes. Was it good? Not so much. Coconut “cream “ would’ve been much better! I doubled this and only put 1/4 of the lime juice. Maybe if I had used the coconut “cream “ I would’ve used more lime.

    1. Krista

      Hey Gina, you’ll have to try it with cream and let me know how it tastes. Everyone I made it for really liked it, but I get everyone has their own tastes.

      1. Rachel

        Maybe I made this wrong, but the texture of the drink was really gross. It was like egg drop soup. It taste fine, but I can’t get past the feel of it.

        1. Krista

          Hey Rachel, I’m so sorry to hear that. You definitely have to give it a good whisk or put it in the blender to smooth out the coconut cream. But once you do that should be perfect.

  12. HW

    I made this for a cookie decorating party. We drank it…because we didn’t want to waste the tequila. The flavors were not for us. Luckily, with tequila, the third drink of any mixer tends to “get better”. Oh well, I love trying new recipes and better luck next time.

  13. Holly Cooley

    Looks amazing! I can’t wait to try it! And your photography is so lovely! I was wondering what you rimmed the glasses with? Thanks!

    1. Krista

      Hey Holly, I did a lime zest and sugar rim on the glasses. Super easy, just 1 tablespoon of granulated sugar with 1 teaspoon of lime zest. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Recipe rating